Characters[]
Main[]
- Captain Jake as Colin Ford/Cameron Boyce/Sean Ryan Fox
- Izzy as Madison Pettis/Megan Richie
- Cubby as Jonathan Morgan Heit/Jadon Sand
- Skully as as David Arquette, speaking; and Loren Hoskins
- Captain Hook as Corey Burton
- Mr. Smee as Jeff Bennett
- Sharky and Bones as Loren Hoskins/Kevin Hendrickson/Jeff Bennett
- Marina the Mermaid as Ariel Winter
- Tick-Tock the Crocodile as Dee Bradley Baker
Recurring[]
- Russi Taylor as Never Bird
- Loren Hoskins as Sandy the Starfish
- Tori Spelling as Pirate Princess
- Lisa Loeb as Winger
- Adam West as Wise Old Parrot
- Jane Kaczmarek as Red Jessica
- Josh Duhamel as Captain Flynn
- Adam Wylie as Peter Pan
- Carol Kane as Sea Witch
- Tiffani Thiessen as Misty the Wonderful Witch
- Jerry O'Connell as Pip the Pirate Genie
- Rhys Darby as Percy the Penguin
- Teri Hatcher as Beatrice Le Beak
- Dee Bradley Baker as Various animals
- Leigh-Allyn Baker as Queen Coralie
- Jack McBrayer as Pirate Mummy
- Bill Farmer as Ghostly Bob
- Maia Mitchell as Wendy Darling
- Elliot Reeve as John Darling
- Colby Mulgrew as Michael Darling
- Estelle Harris as Peg-Leg Peg
- David Tennant as Dread
- Malcolm MacDowell as Lord Fathom
- Mark Hamill as ShiverJack
- Tony Hale as Dr. Undergear
- Christian Slater as The Grim Buccaneer